Gas or diesel?

Compare the fuel cost of a gasoline and a diesel car for your yearly mileage, including extra costs such as diesel maintenance.

mpg$ / gallonExtra costs (DPF, AdBlue etc.)
Gas
Diesel
Result—

Which makes sense?

  • Diesel: pays off on long journeys and high yearly mileage. Constant short urban trips can cause DPF and EGR problems.
  • Gasoline: causes fewer problems in town and at low mileage, and servicing is usually cheaper.
  • Extra costs: enter AdBlue, DPF cleaning or a higher purchase price as an “extra cost”.

Frequently asked questions

At what yearly mileage does diesel make sense?

There is no fixed threshold; it depends on the fuel price gap, the purchase price gap and how you drive. Enter your own figures in the calculator to compare.

Is diesel bad for short trips?

Frequent short trips stop the DPF from regenerating properly, which can lead to warning lights and costly cleaning. For mostly town driving, gasoline or hybrid is usually the safer choice.

Other calculators

Results are estimates based on the values you enter; this is not financial advice.